Differentiate strategist props from Zhuge Liang fan

docs/propfix-fa-zheng-v1-report.md

@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
+# Fa Zheng prop fix v1 report
+
+- source: `propfix-fa-zheng-source-v1.png`
+- base status: ok
+- action status: ok
+- base partial alpha: 0, opaque pixels: 2131622
+- action partial alpha: 0, opaque pixels: 4574401
+- base frame border hits: 0
+- action frame border hits: 0
+- base empty frames: 0
+- action empty frames: 0
+- base bbox width range: 152..250
+- base bbox height range: 282..294
+- base bottom range: 303..303
+- action bbox width range: 131..231
+- action bbox height range: 282..294
+- action bottom range: 303..303
+- contact: `propfix-fa-zheng-v1-contact.png`
+- animation: `propfix-fa-zheng-v1-animation.gif`
+- before/after: `propfix-fa-zheng-v1-before-after.png`
+- scale compare: `propfix-fa-zheng-v1-scale-compare.png`
+- battle composite: `propfix-fa-zheng-v1-battle-composite.png`
+- manual checks: run build and local browser verification after generation
+- note: battle composite is a scale review image; gameplay roster is unchanged during sample approval

docs/propfix-ma-liang-v1-report.md

@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
+# Ma Liang prop fix v1 report
+
+- source: `propfix-ma-liang-source-v1.png`
+- base status: ok
+- action status: ok
+- base partial alpha: 0, opaque pixels: 1934766
+- action partial alpha: 0, opaque pixels: 4224110
+- base frame border hits: 0
+- action frame border hits: 0
+- base empty frames: 0
+- action empty frames: 0
+- base bbox width range: 150..217
+- base bbox height range: 282..290
+- base bottom range: 303..303
+- action bbox width range: 126..204
+- action bbox height range: 282..295
+- action bottom range: 303..303
+- contact: `propfix-ma-liang-v1-contact.png`
+- animation: `propfix-ma-liang-v1-animation.gif`
+- before/after: `propfix-ma-liang-v1-before-after.png`
+- scale compare: `propfix-ma-liang-v1-scale-compare.png`
+- battle composite: `propfix-ma-liang-v1-battle-composite.png`
+- manual checks: run build and local browser verification after generation
+- note: battle composite is a scale review image; gameplay roster is unchanged during sample approval

docs/propfix-pang-tong-v1-report.md

@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
+# Pang Tong prop fix v1 report
+
+- source: `propfix-pang-tong-source-v1.png`
+- base status: ok
+- action status: ok
+- base partial alpha: 0, opaque pixels: 1907114
+- action partial alpha: 0, opaque pixels: 4307606
+- base frame border hits: 0
+- action frame border hits: 0
+- base empty frames: 0
+- action empty frames: 0
+- base bbox width range: 152..205
+- base bbox height range: 282..290
+- base bottom range: 303..303
+- action bbox width range: 131..203
+- action bbox height range: 282..295
+- action bottom range: 303..303
+- contact: `propfix-pang-tong-v1-contact.png`
+- animation: `propfix-pang-tong-v1-animation.gif`
+- before/after: `propfix-pang-tong-v1-before-after.png`
+- scale compare: `propfix-pang-tong-v1-scale-compare.png`
+- battle composite: `propfix-pang-tong-v1-battle-composite.png`
+- manual checks: run build and local browser verification after generation
+- note: battle composite is a scale review image; gameplay roster is unchanged during sample approval

docs/propfix-shu-strategist-v1-report.md

@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
+# Shu Strategist prop fix v1 report
+
+- source: `propfix-shu-strategist-source-v1.png`
+- base status: ok
+- action status: ok
+- base partial alpha: 0, opaque pixels: 2151310
+- action partial alpha: 0, opaque pixels: 4345236
+- base frame border hits: 0
+- action frame border hits: 0
+- base empty frames: 0
+- action empty frames: 0
+- base bbox width range: 149..249
+- base bbox height range: 282..288
+- base bottom range: 303..303
+- action bbox width range: 125..237
+- action bbox height range: 248..288
+- action bottom range: 303..303
+- contact: `propfix-shu-strategist-v1-contact.png`
+- animation: `propfix-shu-strategist-v1-animation.gif`
+- before/after: `propfix-shu-strategist-v1-before-after.png`
+- scale compare: `propfix-shu-strategist-v1-scale-compare.png`
+- battle composite: `propfix-shu-strategist-v1-battle-composite.png`
+- manual checks: run build and local browser verification after generation
+- note: battle composite is a scale review image; gameplay roster is unchanged during sample approval

docs/propfix-sima-yi-v1-report.md

@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
+# Sima Yi prop fix v1 report
+
+- source: `propfix-sima-yi-source-v1.png`
+- base status: ok
+- action status: ok
+- base partial alpha: 0, opaque pixels: 2205012
+- action partial alpha: 0, opaque pixels: 4503608
+- base frame border hits: 0
+- action frame border hits: 0
+- base empty frames: 0
+- action empty frames: 0
+- base bbox width range: 159..237
+- base bbox height range: 282..294
+- base bottom range: 303..303
+- action bbox width range: 137..224
+- action bbox height range: 276..294
+- action bottom range: 303..303
+- contact: `propfix-sima-yi-v1-contact.png`
+- animation: `propfix-sima-yi-v1-animation.gif`
+- before/after: `propfix-sima-yi-v1-before-after.png`
+- scale compare: `propfix-sima-yi-v1-scale-compare.png`
+- battle composite: `propfix-sima-yi-v1-battle-composite.png`
+- manual checks: run build and local browser verification after generation
+- note: battle composite is a scale review image; gameplay roster is unchanged during sample approval

docs/strategist-prop-audit.md

@@ -0,0 +1,45 @@
+# Strategist Prop Audit
+
+This audit keeps Zhuge Liang's large white feather fan as a unique signature prop.
+
+## Prop Rule
+
+- `unit-zhuge-liang` is the only unit allowed to use a large white feather fan silhouette.
+- Other strategist, civil-official, and shaman units should use bamboo slips, scrolls, maps, command tablets, brush cases, small folding fans, talismans, ritual staffs, or faction-specific tools.
+- A fan is acceptable only when it does not read as Zhuge Liang's large white feather fan at 50px battle scale.
+
+## Current Audit
+
+| unit | current prop read | issue | action |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| `unit-zhuge-liang` | large white feather fan | allowed signature prop | keep |
+| `unit-ma-liang` | bamboo slips, bound book, scroll case | white feather fan removed | fixed in batch 1 |
+| `unit-pang-tong` | dark wood slips, compact dark folded fan, scroll bundles | no white feather fan | fixed in batch 1 |
+| `unit-sima-yi` | black command tablet, sealed military order, tally baton | fan removed | fixed in batch 1 |
+| `unit-fa-zheng` | campaign map board, command slips, tally baton | fan removed | fixed in batch 1 |
+| `unit-yi-ji` | letter, bamboo slips, scroll | distinct civil envoy | keep |
+| `unit-huang-quan` | bamboo slips, map board, baton | distinct quartermaster official | keep |
+| `unit-shu-strategist` | writing brush, bamboo slips, compact field map | white feather fan removed | fixed in batch 1 |
+| `unit-shu-strategist-field` | likely strategist prop variant | needs later batch check | later |
+| `unit-shu-strategist-white` | likely pale strategist prop variant | needs later batch check | later |
+| `unit-wei-strategist` | white feather fan in several poses | too close to Zhuge Liang | later prop cleanup |
+| `unit-wei-strategist-black` | dark strategist prop variant | needs later batch check | later |
+| `unit-wei-strategist-blue` | strategist prop variant | needs later batch check | later |
+| `unit-wu-strategist` | white feather fan in several poses | too close to Zhuge Liang | later prop cleanup |
+| `unit-wu-strategist-fire` | white fan in fire strategist poses | too close to Zhuge Liang | later prop cleanup |
+| `unit-wu-strategist-river` | white fan in river strategist poses | too close to Zhuge Liang | later prop cleanup |
+| `unit-nanman-shaman` | ritual staff / tribal ornaments | not a white feather fan | keep |
+| `unit-nanman-shaman-ember` | ritual staff / ember ornaments | not a white feather fan | keep |
+| `unit-nanman-shaman-storm` | ritual staff / storm ornaments | not a white feather fan | keep |
+
+## Representative Fix Batch
+
+The first correction batch changes:
+
+- `unit-ma-liang`
+- `unit-pang-tong`
+- `unit-sima-yi`
+- `unit-fa-zheng`
+- `unit-shu-strategist`
+
+Later cleanup should remove white-feather-fan reads from remaining generic strategist variants after this representative batch is verified.

docs/strategist-propfix-batch1-report.md

@@ -0,0 +1,44 @@
+# Strategist Prop Fix Batch 1
+
+Goal: keep Zhuge Liang's large white feather fan unique, while preserving strategist readability for representative units.
+
+## Units Updated
+
+| unit | old read | new prop direction | result |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| `unit-ma-liang` | white feather fan / soft scholar | bamboo slips, bound book, scroll case, sealed letter | fixed |
+| `unit-pang-tong` | strategist fan pattern | dark wood slips, compact dark folded fan, scroll bundles | fixed |
+| `unit-sima-yi` | gray fan could echo Zhuge Liang | black command tablet, sealed military order, tally baton | fixed |
+| `unit-fa-zheng` | small fan plus command slips | campaign map board, command slips, tally baton | fixed |
+| `unit-shu-strategist` | large white feather fan | writing brush, bamboo slips, compact field map | fixed |
+
+## Deliverables
+
+| unit | contact | animation | before/after | battle preview | browser check |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| `unit-ma-liang` | `docs/propfix-ma-liang-v1-contact.png` | `docs/propfix-ma-liang-v1-animation.gif` | `docs/propfix-ma-liang-v1-before-after.png` | `docs/propfix-ma-liang-v1-battle-composite.png` | `docs/propfix-ma-liang-v1-debug-preview-battle-check.png` |
+| `unit-pang-tong` | `docs/propfix-pang-tong-v1-contact.png` | `docs/propfix-pang-tong-v1-animation.gif` | `docs/propfix-pang-tong-v1-before-after.png` | `docs/propfix-pang-tong-v1-battle-composite.png` | `docs/propfix-pang-tong-v1-debug-preview-battle-check.png` |
+| `unit-sima-yi` | `docs/propfix-sima-yi-v1-contact.png` | `docs/propfix-sima-yi-v1-animation.gif` | `docs/propfix-sima-yi-v1-before-after.png` | `docs/propfix-sima-yi-v1-battle-composite.png` | `docs/propfix-sima-yi-v1-debug-preview-battle-check.png` |
+| `unit-fa-zheng` | `docs/propfix-fa-zheng-v1-contact.png` | `docs/propfix-fa-zheng-v1-animation.gif` | `docs/propfix-fa-zheng-v1-before-after.png` | `docs/propfix-fa-zheng-v1-battle-composite.png` | `docs/propfix-fa-zheng-v1-debug-preview-battle-check.png` |
+| `unit-shu-strategist` | `docs/propfix-shu-strategist-v1-contact.png` | `docs/propfix-shu-strategist-v1-animation.gif` | `docs/propfix-shu-strategist-v1-before-after.png` | `docs/propfix-shu-strategist-v1-battle-composite.png` | `docs/propfix-shu-strategist-v1-debug-preview-battle-check.png` |
+
+## Technical Verification
+
+- `pnpm build`: passed.
+- `scripts/audit-unit-sprite-sheets.py`: passed for updated sheets.
+- `scripts/check-unit-sprite-approval-gate.py --mode release`: passed.
+- `scripts/check-unit-sprite-workflow-consistency.py`: passed.
+- Local browser checks: 5/5 passed.
+- Local browser console errors: `0`.
+- Local browser 404s: `0`.
+
+## Follow-Up Queue
+
+The representative batch fixes the most visible overlap. Remaining generic variants that still need later prop cleanup:
+
+- `unit-wei-strategist`
+- `unit-wu-strategist`
+- `unit-wu-strategist-fire`
+- `unit-wu-strategist-river`
+- `unit-shu-strategist-field`
+- `unit-shu-strategist-white`

docs/unit-sprite-batch-queue.json

@@ -430,10 +430,10 @@
           "baseStatus": "ok",
           "actionStatus": "ok",
           "battleBasePx": [
-            24.9,
+            23.8,
-            34.2,
+            39.8,
             45.0,
-            46.8
+            46.0
           ],
           "spec": "unit-sprite-batch2-shu-strategist-spec.md"
         },
@@ -1208,10 +1208,10 @@
           "baseStatus": "ok",
           "actionStatus": "ok",
           "battleBasePx": [
-            29.1,
+            24.3,
-            35.3,
+            39.9,
-            46.3,
+            45.0,
-            46.3
+            47.0
           ],
           "spec": null
         },
@@ -1348,9 +1348,9 @@
           "baseStatus": "ok",
           "actionStatus": "ok",
           "battleBasePx": [
-            25.6,
+            24.0,
-            38.8,
+            34.7,
-            46.3,
+            45.0,
             46.3
           ],
           "spec": null
@@ -1362,10 +1362,10 @@
           "baseStatus": "ok",
           "actionStatus": "ok",
           "battleBasePx": [
-            28.0,
+            24.3,
-            32.1,
+            32.7,
-            46.0,
+            45.0,
-            46.0
+            46.3
           ],
           "spec": null
         },
@@ -1376,10 +1376,10 @@
           "baseStatus": "ok",
           "actionStatus": "ok",
           "battleBasePx": [
-            31.3,
+            25.4,
-            33.5,
+            37.9,
-            46.0,
+            45.0,
-            46.0
+            47.0
           ],
           "spec": null
         },

docs/unit-sprite-batch-queue.md

@@ -65,7 +65,7 @@ No next unit is currently defined.
 | `unit-shu-spearman` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 23.3..42.0 x 43.8..46.3 | `unit-sprite-batch2-shu-spearman-spec.md` |
 | `unit-shu-spearman-guard` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 29.4..32.7 x 44.2..47.1 |  |
 | `unit-shu-spearman-veteran` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 26.0..32.9 x 46.3..47.1 |  |
-| `unit-shu-strategist` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 24.9..34.2 x 45.0..46.8 | `unit-sprite-batch2-shu-strategist-spec.md` |
+| `unit-shu-strategist` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 23.8..39.8 x 45.0..46.0 | `unit-sprite-batch2-shu-strategist-spec.md` |
 | `unit-shu-strategist-field` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 26.5..32.9 x 44.2..47.1 |  |
 | `unit-shu-strategist-white` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 24.9..32.7 x 44.2..47.1 |  |
 
@@ -162,7 +162,7 @@ No next unit is currently defined.
 | unit | role | stage | status | battle base px | spec |
 | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
 | `unit-cao-cao` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 32.9..36.4 x 46.3..47.3 |  |
-| `unit-fa-zheng` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 29.1..35.3 x 46.3..46.3 |  |
+| `unit-fa-zheng` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 24.3..39.9 x 45.0..47.0 |  |
 | `unit-gong-zhi` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 33.2..35.5 x 46.3..46.3 |  |
 | `unit-huang-quan` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 28.9..34.8 x 46.3..46.3 |  |
 | `unit-huang-zhong` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 27.2..36.3 x 46.3..47.3 |  |
@@ -172,9 +172,9 @@ No next unit is currently defined.
 | `unit-lu-meng` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 27.0..40.4 x 46.0..46.3 |  |
 | `unit-ma-chao` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 26.5..42.0 x 46.0..47.3 |  |
 | `unit-ma-dai` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 27.0..39.8 x 46.0..46.3 |  |
-| `unit-ma-liang` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 25.6..38.8 x 46.3..46.3 |  |
+| `unit-ma-liang` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 24.0..34.7 x 45.0..46.3 |  |
-| `unit-pang-tong` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 28.0..32.1 x 46.0..46.0 |  |
+| `unit-pang-tong` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 24.3..32.7 x 45.0..46.3 |  |
-| `unit-sima-yi` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 31.3..33.5 x 46.0..46.0 |  |
+| `unit-sima-yi` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 25.4..37.9 x 45.0..47.0 |  |
 | `unit-wang-ping` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 28.0..33.7 x 45.7..46.0 |  |
 | `unit-yan-yan` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 30.4..37.5 x 45.7..46.0 |  |
 | `unit-yi-ji` | approved reference | approved-baseline | technical ok | 27.8..33.9 x 45.7..46.0 |  |

docs/unit-sprite-rework-audit.json

@@ -83,22 +83,22 @@
           1252
         ],
         "partial_alpha": 0,
-        "opaque_pixels": 2296062,
+        "opaque_pixels": 2131622,
         "border_hits": 0,
-        "min_width": 182,
+        "min_width": 152,
-        "max_width": 221,
+        "max_width": 250,
-        "min_height": 290,
+        "min_height": 282,
-        "max_height": 290,
+        "max_height": 294,
         "min_bottom": 303,
         "max_bottom": 303,
         "empty_frames": 0,
-        "width_swing": 39,
+        "width_swing": 98,
-        "height_swing": 0,
+        "height_swing": 12,
         "bottom_swing": 0,
-        "battle_min_width_px": 29.1,
+        "battle_min_width_px": 24.3,
-        "battle_max_width_px": 35.3,
+        "battle_max_width_px": 39.9,
-        "battle_min_height_px": 46.3,
+        "battle_min_height_px": 45.0,
-        "battle_max_height_px": 46.3,
+        "battle_max_height_px": 47.0,
         "status": "ok"
       },
       "actions": {
@@ -109,22 +109,22 @@
           1252
         ],
         "partial_alpha": 0,
-        "opaque_pixels": 5507911,
+        "opaque_pixels": 4574401,
         "border_hits": 0,
-        "min_width": 183,
+        "min_width": 131,
-        "max_width": 244,
+        "max_width": 231,
-        "min_height": 270,
+        "min_height": 282,
-        "max_height": 290,
+        "max_height": 294,
         "min_bottom": 303,
         "max_bottom": 303,
         "empty_frames": 0,
-        "width_swing": 61,
+        "width_swing": 100,
-        "height_swing": 20,
+        "height_swing": 12,
         "bottom_swing": 0,
-        "battle_min_width_px": 29.2,
+        "battle_min_width_px": 20.9,
-        "battle_max_width_px": 39.0,
+        "battle_max_width_px": 36.9,
-        "battle_min_height_px": 43.1,
+        "battle_min_height_px": 45.0,
-        "battle_max_height_px": 46.3,
+        "battle_max_height_px": 47.0,
         "status": "ok"
       }
     },
@@ -767,21 +767,21 @@
           1252
         ],
         "partial_alpha": 0,
-        "opaque_pixels": 2452368,
+        "opaque_pixels": 1934766,
         "border_hits": 0,
-        "min_width": 160,
+        "min_width": 150,
-        "max_width": 243,
+        "max_width": 217,
-        "min_height": 290,
+        "min_height": 282,
         "max_height": 290,
         "min_bottom": 303,
         "max_bottom": 303,
         "empty_frames": 0,
-        "width_swing": 83,
+        "width_swing": 67,
-        "height_swing": 0,
+        "height_swing": 8,
         "bottom_swing": 0,
-        "battle_min_width_px": 25.6,
+        "battle_min_width_px": 24.0,
-        "battle_max_width_px": 38.8,
+        "battle_max_width_px": 34.7,
-        "battle_min_height_px": 46.3,
+        "battle_min_height_px": 45.0,
         "battle_max_height_px": 46.3,
         "status": "ok"
       },
@@ -793,22 +793,22 @@
           1252
         ],
         "partial_alpha": 0,
-        "opaque_pixels": 6122211,
+        "opaque_pixels": 4224110,
         "border_hits": 0,
-        "min_width": 160,
+        "min_width": 126,
-        "max_width": 264,
+        "max_width": 204,
-        "min_height": 286,
+        "min_height": 282,
-        "max_height": 290,
+        "max_height": 295,
         "min_bottom": 303,
         "max_bottom": 303,
         "empty_frames": 0,
-        "width_swing": 104,
+        "width_swing": 78,
-        "height_swing": 4,
+        "height_swing": 13,
         "bottom_swing": 0,
-        "battle_min_width_px": 25.6,
+        "battle_min_width_px": 20.1,
-        "battle_max_width_px": 42.2,
+        "battle_max_width_px": 32.6,
-        "battle_min_height_px": 45.7,
+        "battle_min_height_px": 45.0,
-        "battle_max_height_px": 46.3,
+        "battle_max_height_px": 47.1,
         "status": "ok"
       }
     },
@@ -1394,22 +1394,22 @@
           1252
         ],
         "partial_alpha": 0,
-        "opaque_pixels": 2067632,
+        "opaque_pixels": 1907114,
         "border_hits": 0,
-        "min_width": 175,
+        "min_width": 152,
-        "max_width": 201,
+        "max_width": 205,
-        "min_height": 288,
+        "min_height": 282,
-        "max_height": 288,
+        "max_height": 290,
         "min_bottom": 303,
         "max_bottom": 303,
         "empty_frames": 0,
-        "width_swing": 26,
+        "width_swing": 53,
-        "height_swing": 0,
+        "height_swing": 8,
         "bottom_swing": 0,
-        "battle_min_width_px": 28.0,
+        "battle_min_width_px": 24.3,
-        "battle_max_width_px": 32.1,
+        "battle_max_width_px": 32.7,
-        "battle_min_height_px": 46.0,
+        "battle_min_height_px": 45.0,
-        "battle_max_height_px": 46.0,
+        "battle_max_height_px": 46.3,
         "status": "ok"
       },
       "actions": {
@@ -1420,22 +1420,22 @@
           1252
         ],
         "partial_alpha": 0,
-        "opaque_pixels": 5101099,
+        "opaque_pixels": 4307606,
         "border_hits": 0,
-        "min_width": 164,
+        "min_width": 131,
-        "max_width": 273,
+        "max_width": 203,
-        "min_height": 286,
+        "min_height": 282,
-        "max_height": 290,
+        "max_height": 295,
         "min_bottom": 303,
         "max_bottom": 303,
         "empty_frames": 0,
-        "width_swing": 109,
+        "width_swing": 72,
-        "height_swing": 4,
+        "height_swing": 13,
         "bottom_swing": 0,
-        "battle_min_width_px": 26.2,
+        "battle_min_width_px": 20.9,
-        "battle_max_width_px": 43.6,
+        "battle_max_width_px": 32.4,
-        "battle_min_height_px": 45.7,
+        "battle_min_height_px": 45.0,
-        "battle_max_height_px": 46.3,
+        "battle_max_height_px": 47.1,
         "status": "ok"
       }
     },
@@ -2819,22 +2819,22 @@
           1252
         ],
         "partial_alpha": 0,
-        "opaque_pixels": 2006886,
+        "opaque_pixels": 2151310,
         "border_hits": 0,
-        "min_width": 156,
+        "min_width": 149,
-        "max_width": 214,
+        "max_width": 249,
         "min_height": 282,
-        "max_height": 293,
+        "max_height": 288,
         "min_bottom": 303,
         "max_bottom": 303,
         "empty_frames": 0,
-        "width_swing": 58,
+        "width_swing": 100,
-        "height_swing": 11,
+        "height_swing": 6,
         "bottom_swing": 0,
-        "battle_min_width_px": 24.9,
+        "battle_min_width_px": 23.8,
-        "battle_max_width_px": 34.2,
+        "battle_max_width_px": 39.8,
         "battle_min_height_px": 45.0,
-        "battle_max_height_px": 46.8,
+        "battle_max_height_px": 46.0,
         "status": "ok"
       },
       "actions": {
@@ -2845,22 +2845,22 @@
           1252
         ],
         "partial_alpha": 0,
-        "opaque_pixels": 5055851,
+        "opaque_pixels": 4345236,
         "border_hits": 0,
-        "min_width": 155,
+        "min_width": 125,
-        "max_width": 243,
+        "max_width": 237,
-        "min_height": 282,
+        "min_height": 248,
-        "max_height": 293,
+        "max_height": 288,
         "min_bottom": 303,
         "max_bottom": 303,
         "empty_frames": 0,
-        "width_swing": 88,
+        "width_swing": 112,
-        "height_swing": 11,
+        "height_swing": 40,
         "bottom_swing": 0,
-        "battle_min_width_px": 24.8,
+        "battle_min_width_px": 20.0,
-        "battle_max_width_px": 38.8,
+        "battle_max_width_px": 37.9,
-        "battle_min_height_px": 45.0,
+        "battle_min_height_px": 39.6,
-        "battle_max_height_px": 46.8,
+        "battle_max_height_px": 46.0,
         "status": "ok"
       }
     },
@@ -2990,22 +2990,22 @@
           1252
         ],
         "partial_alpha": 0,
-        "opaque_pixels": 2302994,
+        "opaque_pixels": 2205012,
         "border_hits": 0,
-        "min_width": 196,
+        "min_width": 159,
-        "max_width": 210,
+        "max_width": 237,
-        "min_height": 288,
+        "min_height": 282,
-        "max_height": 288,
+        "max_height": 294,
         "min_bottom": 303,
         "max_bottom": 303,
         "empty_frames": 0,
-        "width_swing": 14,
+        "width_swing": 78,
-        "height_swing": 0,
+        "height_swing": 12,
         "bottom_swing": 0,
-        "battle_min_width_px": 31.3,
+        "battle_min_width_px": 25.4,
-        "battle_max_width_px": 33.5,
+        "battle_max_width_px": 37.9,
-        "battle_min_height_px": 46.0,
+        "battle_min_height_px": 45.0,
-        "battle_max_height_px": 46.0,
+        "battle_max_height_px": 47.0,
         "status": "ok"
       },
       "actions": {
@@ -3016,22 +3016,22 @@
           1252
         ],
         "partial_alpha": 0,
-        "opaque_pixels": 5483833,
+        "opaque_pixels": 4503608,
         "border_hits": 0,
-        "min_width": 180,
+        "min_width": 137,
-        "max_width": 267,
+        "max_width": 224,
-        "min_height": 286,
+        "min_height": 276,
-        "max_height": 290,
+        "max_height": 294,
         "min_bottom": 303,
         "max_bottom": 303,
         "empty_frames": 0,
         "width_swing": 87,
-        "height_swing": 4,
+        "height_swing": 18,
         "bottom_swing": 0,
-        "battle_min_width_px": 28.8,
+        "battle_min_width_px": 21.9,
-        "battle_max_width_px": 42.7,
+        "battle_max_width_px": 35.8,
-        "battle_min_height_px": 45.7,
+        "battle_min_height_px": 44.1,
-        "battle_max_height_px": 46.3,
+        "battle_max_height_px": 47.0,
         "status": "ok"
       }
     },

docs/unit-sprite-rework-audit.md

@@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ Visual review boards are generated by `scripts/render-unit-sprite-review-boards.
 | batch | stage | stem | base | actions | base bbox | action bbox | battle base px | motion swing |
 | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
 | batch7-unique-officer | approved-baseline | `unit-cao-cao` | ok | ok | 206..228 x 290..296 | 186..252 x 270..296 | 32.9..36.4 x 46.3..47.3 | w22 h6 b0 |
-| batch7-unique-officer | approved-baseline | `unit-fa-zheng` | ok | ok | 182..221 x 290..290 | 183..244 x 270..290 | 29.1..35.3 x 46.3..46.3 | w39 h0 b0 |
+| batch7-unique-officer | approved-baseline | `unit-fa-zheng` | ok | ok | 152..250 x 282..294 | 131..231 x 282..294 | 24.3..39.9 x 45.0..47.0 | w98 h12 b0 |
 | batch7-unique-officer | approved-baseline | `unit-gong-zhi` | ok | ok | 208..222 x 290..290 | 196..287 x 270..290 | 33.2..35.5 x 46.3..46.3 | w14 h0 b0 |
 | batch1-approved-core | approved-baseline | `unit-guan-yu` | ok | ok | 190..270 x 276..291 | 172..296 x 171..289 | 30.4..43.1 x 44.1..46.5 | w80 h15 b4 |
 | batch7-unique-officer | approved-baseline | `unit-huang-quan` | ok | ok | 181..218 x 290..290 | 176..251 x 284..290 | 28.9..34.8 x 46.3..46.3 | w37 h0 b0 |
@@ -64,7 +64,7 @@ Visual review boards are generated by `scripts/render-unit-sprite-review-boards.
 | batch7-unique-officer | approved-baseline | `unit-lu-meng` | ok | ok | 169..253 x 288..290 | 153..238 x 286..290 | 27.0..40.4 x 46.0..46.3 | w84 h2 b0 |
 | batch7-unique-officer | approved-baseline | `unit-ma-chao` | ok | ok | 166..263 x 288..296 | 166..263 x 284..296 | 26.5..42.0 x 46.0..47.3 | w97 h8 b0 |
 | batch7-unique-officer | approved-baseline | `unit-ma-dai` | ok | ok | 169..249 x 288..290 | 162..239 x 284..290 | 27.0..39.8 x 46.0..46.3 | w80 h2 b0 |
-| batch7-unique-officer | approved-baseline | `unit-ma-liang` | ok | ok | 160..243 x 290..290 | 160..264 x 286..290 | 25.6..38.8 x 46.3..46.3 | w83 h0 b0 |
+| batch7-unique-officer | approved-baseline | `unit-ma-liang` | ok | ok | 150..217 x 282..290 | 126..204 x 282..295 | 24.0..34.7 x 45.0..46.3 | w67 h8 b0 |
 | batch6-nanman-special | approved-baseline | `unit-meng-huo` | ok | ok | 174..221 x 286..288 | 149..248 x 275..289 | 27.8..35.3 x 45.7..46.0 | w47 h2 b0 |
 | batch6-nanman-special | approved-baseline | `unit-nanman-infantry` | ok | ok | 152..219 x 288..288 | 152..243 x 265..288 | 24.3..35.0 x 46.0..46.0 | w67 h0 b0 |
 | batch6-nanman-special | approved-baseline | `unit-nanman-infantry-jungle` | ok | ok | 172..209 x 286..288 | 158..247 x 282..288 | 27.5..33.4 x 45.7..46.0 | w37 h2 b0 |
@@ -75,7 +75,7 @@ Visual review boards are generated by `scripts/render-unit-sprite-review-boards.
 | batch6-nanman-special | approved-baseline | `unit-nanman-shaman` | ok | ok | 190..214 x 288..288 | 197..263 x 277..290 | 30.4..34.2 x 46.0..46.0 | w24 h0 b0 |
 | batch6-nanman-special | approved-baseline | `unit-nanman-shaman-ember` | ok | ok | 180..212 x 288..290 | 180..242 x 264..290 | 28.8..33.9 x 46.0..46.3 | w32 h2 b0 |
 | batch6-nanman-special | approved-baseline | `unit-nanman-shaman-storm` | ok | ok | 195..223 x 286..290 | 195..245 x 240..290 | 31.2..35.6 x 45.7..46.3 | w28 h4 b0 |
-| batch7-unique-officer | approved-baseline | `unit-pang-tong` | ok | ok | 175..201 x 288..288 | 164..273 x 286..290 | 28.0..32.1 x 46.0..46.0 | w26 h0 b0 |
+| batch7-unique-officer | approved-baseline | `unit-pang-tong` | ok | ok | 152..205 x 282..290 | 131..203 x 282..295 | 24.3..32.7 x 45.0..46.3 | w53 h8 b0 |
 | batch1-approved-rebel | approved-baseline | `unit-rebel` | ok | ok | 195..284 x 271..281 | 180..286 x 178..289 | 31.2..45.4 x 43.3..44.9 | w89 h10 b8 |
 | batch1-approved-rebel | approved-baseline | `unit-rebel-archer` | ok | ok | 185..263 x 272..278 | 116..284 x 228..288 | 29.6..42.0 x 43.5..44.4 | w78 h6 b1 |
 | batch5-rebel-other | approved-baseline | `unit-rebel-archer-fire` | ok | ok | 161..249 x 288..295 | 161..252 x 285..295 | 25.7..39.8 x 46.0..47.1 | w88 h7 b0 |
@@ -100,10 +100,10 @@ Visual review boards are generated by `scripts/render-unit-sprite-review-boards.
 | batch2-shu | approved-baseline | `unit-shu-spearman` | ok | ok | 146..263 x 274..290 | 146..276 x 280..295 | 23.3..42.0 x 43.8..46.3 | w117 h16 b0 |
 | batch2-shu | approved-baseline | `unit-shu-spearman-guard` | ok | ok | 184..205 x 277..295 | 176..276 x 232..295 | 29.4..32.7 x 44.2..47.1 | w21 h18 b0 |
 | batch2-shu | approved-baseline | `unit-shu-spearman-veteran` | ok | ok | 163..206 x 290..295 | 143..276 x 221..295 | 26.0..32.9 x 46.3..47.1 | w43 h5 b0 |
-| batch2-shu | approved-baseline | `unit-shu-strategist` | ok | ok | 156..214 x 282..293 | 155..243 x 282..293 | 24.9..34.2 x 45.0..46.8 | w58 h11 b0 |
+| batch2-shu | approved-baseline | `unit-shu-strategist` | ok | ok | 149..249 x 282..288 | 125..237 x 248..288 | 23.8..39.8 x 45.0..46.0 | w100 h6 b0 |
 | batch2-shu | approved-baseline | `unit-shu-strategist-field` | ok | ok | 166..206 x 277..295 | 166..269 x 277..295 | 26.5..32.9 x 44.2..47.1 | w40 h18 b0 |
 | batch2-shu | approved-baseline | `unit-shu-strategist-white` | ok | ok | 156..205 x 277..295 | 156..269 x 276..295 | 24.9..32.7 x 44.2..47.1 | w49 h18 b0 |
-| batch7-unique-officer | approved-baseline | `unit-sima-yi` | ok | ok | 196..210 x 288..288 | 180..267 x 286..290 | 31.3..33.5 x 46.0..46.0 | w14 h0 b0 |
+| batch7-unique-officer | approved-baseline | `unit-sima-yi` | ok | ok | 159..237 x 282..294 | 137..224 x 276..294 | 25.4..37.9 x 45.0..47.0 | w78 h12 b0 |
 | batch7-unique-officer | approved-baseline | `unit-wang-ping` | ok | ok | 175..211 x 286..288 | 158..256 x 286..295 | 28.0..33.7 x 45.7..46.0 | w36 h2 b0 |
 | batch3-wei | approved-baseline | `unit-wei-archer` | ok | ok | 190..245 x 288..296 | 190..245 x 282..296 | 30.4..39.1 x 46.0..47.3 | w55 h8 b0 |
 | batch3-wei | approved-baseline | `unit-wei-archer-crossbow` | ok | ok | 186..230 x 288..290 | 169..276 x 249..290 | 29.7..36.7 x 46.0..46.3 | w44 h2 b0 |