From 7dd437c45dd20a0b8c6ac9faa804e0ad02f00529 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Wickedness <y2keui@nate.com>
Date: Sat, 27 Jun 2026 12:21:14 +0900
Subject: [PATCH] QA and tune refuge campaign battles

---
 scripts/qa-representative-battles.mjs | 108 +++++++++-
 src/game/data/battles.ts              |  14 +-
 src/game/data/scenario.ts             | 286 +++++++++++++-------------
 src/game/scenes/BattleScene.ts        |   8 +-
 src/game/scenes/CampScene.ts          |   4 +-
 5 files changed, 258 insertions(+), 162 deletions(-)

diff --git a/scripts/qa-representative-battles.mjs b/scripts/qa-representative-battles.mjs
index 80c4c31..1a1fe7c 100644
--- a/scripts/qa-representative-battles.mjs
+++ b/scripts/qa-representative-battles.mjs
@@ -8,6 +8,11 @@ const pnpmCommand = process.env.PNPM_CMD ?? 'pnpm';
 
 const coreBrothers = ['liu-bei', 'guan-yu', 'zhang-fei'];
 const xuzhouFullSortie = ['liu-bei', 'guan-yu', 'zhang-fei', 'jian-yong', 'mi-zhu'];
+const caoRefugeSortie = ['liu-bei', 'guan-yu', 'zhang-fei', 'jian-yong', 'mi-zhu'];
+const sunQianSortie = ['liu-bei', 'guan-yu', 'zhang-fei', 'jian-yong', 'mi-zhu', 'sun-qian'];
+const liuBiaoSortie = ['liu-bei', 'guan-yu', 'zhang-fei', 'zhao-yun', 'sun-qian', 'mi-zhu'];
+const zhugeFirstSortie = ['liu-bei', 'zhuge-liang', 'zhao-yun', 'guan-yu', 'zhang-fei', 'sun-qian'];
+const envoySortie = ['liu-bei', 'zhuge-liang', 'sun-qian', 'zhao-yun', 'guan-yu', 'zhang-fei'];
 
 const earlyCampaignBattles = [
   { no: 1, id: 'first-battle-zhuo-commandery', selected: [], targets: ['rebel-leader'], protected: ['liu-bei'] },
@@ -76,6 +81,79 @@ const earlyCampaignBattles = [
   }
 ];
 
+const refugeCampaignBattles = [
+  {
+    no: 11,
+    id: 'eleventh-battle-xudu-refuge-road',
+    selected: caoRefugeSortie,
+    targets: ['xudu-road-leader-ji-ling'],
+    protected: ['liu-bei']
+  },
+  {
+    no: 12,
+    id: 'twelfth-battle-xiapi-outer-siege',
+    selected: caoRefugeSortie,
+    targets: ['xiapi-leader-zhang-liao'],
+    protected: ['liu-bei']
+  },
+  {
+    no: 13,
+    id: 'thirteenth-battle-xiapi-final',
+    selected: caoRefugeSortie,
+    targets: ['xiapi-final-leader-lu-bu'],
+    protected: ['liu-bei']
+  },
+  {
+    no: 14,
+    id: 'fourteenth-battle-cao-break',
+    selected: sunQianSortie,
+    targets: ['cao-break-leader-che-zhou'],
+    protected: ['liu-bei']
+  },
+  {
+    no: 15,
+    id: 'fifteenth-battle-yuan-refuge-road',
+    selected: sunQianSortie,
+    targets: ['yuan-refuge-leader-cai-yang'],
+    protected: ['liu-bei']
+  },
+  {
+    no: 16,
+    id: 'sixteenth-battle-liu-biao-refuge',
+    selected: liuBiaoSortie,
+    targets: ['liu-biao-road-leader-cao-ren'],
+    protected: ['liu-bei']
+  },
+  {
+    no: 17,
+    id: 'seventeenth-battle-wolong-visit-road',
+    selected: liuBiaoSortie,
+    targets: ['wolong-road-leader-cai-xun'],
+    protected: ['liu-bei']
+  },
+  {
+    no: 18,
+    id: 'eighteenth-battle-bowang-ambush',
+    selected: zhugeFirstSortie,
+    targets: ['bowang-leader-xiahou-dun'],
+    protected: ['liu-bei']
+  },
+  {
+    no: 19,
+    id: 'nineteenth-battle-changban-refuge',
+    selected: zhugeFirstSortie,
+    targets: ['changban-leader-cao-chun'],
+    protected: ['liu-bei', 'zhao-yun']
+  },
+  {
+    no: 20,
+    id: 'twentieth-battle-jiangdong-envoy',
+    selected: envoySortie,
+    targets: ['envoy-road-leader-wen-pin'],
+    protected: ['liu-bei', 'zhuge-liang', 'sun-qian']
+  }
+];
+
 const allRepresentativeBattles = [
   { no: 1, id: 'first-battle-zhuo-commandery', selected: [], targets: ['rebel-leader'], protected: ['liu-bei'] },
   {
@@ -138,7 +216,8 @@ const allRepresentativeBattles = [
 
 const qaBattleSets = {
   representative: allRepresentativeBattles,
-  early: earlyCampaignBattles
+  early: earlyCampaignBattles,
+  refuge: refugeCampaignBattles
 };
 const qaSetName = process.env.QA_SET ?? 'representative';
 const qaBattleSet = qaBattleSets[qaSetName];
@@ -402,7 +481,14 @@ async function playBattleWithoutDebugVictory(page, battle) {
         if (vanguards.length === 0) {
           return unit.hp >= Math.ceil(unit.maxHp * 0.8);
         }
-        return Boolean(vanguardInPosition && focus && targetIds.has(focus.id) && focus.hp <= Math.ceil(focus.maxHp * 0.3));
+        const targetPressThreshold = protectedIds.size > 1 ? 0.12 : 0.3;
+        return Boolean(
+          vanguardInPosition &&
+            focus &&
+            targetIds.has(focus.id) &&
+            focus.hp <= Math.ceil(focus.maxHp * targetPressThreshold) &&
+            unit.hp >= Math.ceil(unit.maxHp * 0.7)
+        );
       }
 
       function canTakeAttack(unit, attack, threat = protectedIds.has(unit.id) ? incomingThreat(unit, unit) : 0) {
@@ -412,7 +498,16 @@ async function playBattleWithoutDebugVictory(page, battle) {
         const pressProtected = shouldPressProtected(unit);
         const isTarget = targetIds.has(attack.target.id);
         const kill = attack.preview.damage >= attack.target.hp;
-        if (isTarget && (threat <= Math.floor(unit.hp * (pressProtected ? 0.7 : 0.42)) || unit.hp >= Math.ceil(unit.maxHp * 0.8))) {
+        if (protectedIds.size > 1 && !isTarget && unit.id === 'sun-qian') {
+          return kill && liveUnits('enemy').length <= 3 && threat <= Math.floor(unit.hp * 0.12);
+        }
+        if (protectedIds.size > 1 && !isTarget) {
+          return unit.hp >= Math.ceil(unit.maxHp * 0.75) && threat <= Math.floor(unit.hp * 0.22);
+        }
+        if (isTarget && (pressProtected || kill) && threat <= Math.floor(unit.hp * (pressProtected ? 0.7 : 0.42))) {
+          return true;
+        }
+        if (isTarget && protectedIds.size === 1 && threat <= Math.floor(unit.hp * 0.3)) {
           return true;
         }
         if (kill && threat <= Math.floor(unit.hp * (pressProtected ? 0.5 : 0.32))) {
@@ -489,10 +584,11 @@ async function playBattleWithoutDebugVictory(page, battle) {
             const focus = attack?.target ?? focusTarget(unit);
             const isProtected = protectedIds.has(unit.id);
             const shouldPress = isProtected && shouldPressProtected(unit);
-            const approach = focus ? -distance(unit, focus) * (isProtected ? (shouldPress ? 42 : 5) : 36) : 0;
-            const attackScore = attack ? attack.score + (targetIds.has(attack.target.id) ? 2400 : 1350) : approach;
-            const allySupport = liveUnits('ally').filter((ally) => ally.id !== unit.id && distance(unit, ally) <= 2).length * 16;
             const threat = incomingThreat(unit, tile);
+            const canUseAttack = attack && (!isProtected || canTakeAttack(unit, attack, threat));
+            const approach = focus ? -distance(unit, focus) * (isProtected ? (shouldPress ? 42 : 5) : 36) : 0;
+            const attackScore = canUseAttack ? attack.score + (targetIds.has(attack.target.id) ? 2400 : 1350) : approach;
+            const allySupport = liveUnits('ally').filter((ally) => ally.id !== unit.id && distance(unit, ally) <= 2).length * 16;
             const nearestEnemyDistance = liveUnits('enemy')
               .map((enemy) => distance(unit, enemy))
               .sort((a, b) => a - b)[0] ?? 99;
diff --git a/src/game/data/battles.ts b/src/game/data/battles.ts
index 31dd40f..da7aaf5 100644
--- a/src/game/data/battles.ts
+++ b/src/game/data/battles.ts
@@ -1164,7 +1164,7 @@ export const fifteenthBattleScenario: BattleScenarioDefinition = {
     }
   ],
   defeatConditions: [{ kind: 'unit-defeated', unitId: 'liu-bei' }],
-  itemRewards: ['콩 6', '상처약 3', '탁주 2', '원소 접선 문서 +1'],
+  itemRewards: ['콩 6', '상처약 4', '탁주 2', '원소 접선 문서 +1'],
   victoryPages: fifteenthBattleVictoryPages,
   nextCampScene: 'CampScene'
 };
@@ -1217,7 +1217,7 @@ export const sixteenthBattleScenario: BattleScenarioDefinition = {
     }
   ],
   defeatConditions: [{ kind: 'unit-defeated', unitId: 'liu-bei' }],
-  itemRewards: ['콩 6', '상처약 4', '탁주 2', '형주 접선 문서 +1'],
+  itemRewards: ['콩 6', '상처약 5', '탁주 2', '형주 접선 문서 +1'],
   victoryPages: sixteenthBattleVictoryPages,
   nextCampScene: 'CampScene'
 };
@@ -1270,7 +1270,7 @@ export const seventeenthBattleScenario: BattleScenarioDefinition = {
     }
   ],
   defeatConditions: [{ kind: 'unit-defeated', unitId: 'liu-bei' }],
-  itemRewards: ['콩 6', '상처약 4', '탁주 2', '와룡의 서찰 +1'],
+  itemRewards: ['콩 6', '상처약 5', '탁주 2', '와룡의 서찰 +1'],
   victoryPages: seventeenthBattleVictoryPages,
   nextCampScene: 'CampScene'
 };
@@ -1406,7 +1406,7 @@ export const twentiethBattleScenario: BattleScenarioDefinition = {
   bonds: twentiethBattleBonds,
   mapTextureKey: 'battle-map-twentieth',
   leaderUnitId: 'envoy-road-leader-wen-pin',
-  quickVictoryTurnLimit: 29,
+  quickVictoryTurnLimit: 31,
   baseVictoryGold: 2380,
   objectives: [
     {
@@ -1440,9 +1440,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleScenario: BattleScenarioDefinition = {
     {
       id: 'quick',
       kind: 'quick-victory',
-      label: '29턴 이내 승리',
+      label: '31턴 이내 승리',
       rewardGold: 640,
-      maxTurn: 29
+      maxTurn: 31
     }
   ],
   defeatConditions: [
@@ -1450,7 +1450,7 @@ export const twentiethBattleScenario: BattleScenarioDefinition = {
     { kind: 'unit-defeated', unitId: 'zhuge-liang' },
     { kind: 'unit-defeated', unitId: 'sun-qian' }
   ],
-  itemRewards: ['콩 8', '상처약 5', '탁주 3', '강동 사절 문서 +1', '화공 논의 +1'],
+  itemRewards: ['콩 8', '상처약 6', '탁주 3', '강동 사절 문서 +1', '화공 논의 +1'],
   victoryPages: twentiethBattleVictoryPages,
   nextCampScene: 'CampScene'
 };
diff --git a/src/game/data/scenario.ts b/src/game/data/scenario.ts
index d8e63d3..d678aee 100644
--- a/src/game/data/scenario.ts
+++ b/src/game/data/scenario.ts
@@ -9008,9 +9008,9 @@ export const fifteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'bandit',
     level: 15,
     exp: 92,
-    hp: 54,
+    hp: 48,
     maxHp: 54,
-    attack: 20,
+    attack: 18,
     move: 4,
     stats: { might: 90, intelligence: 62, leadership: 68, agility: 88, luck: 62 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9029,9 +9029,9 @@ export const fifteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'bandit',
     level: 15,
     exp: 92,
-    hp: 54,
+    hp: 48,
     maxHp: 54,
-    attack: 20,
+    attack: 18,
     move: 4,
     stats: { might: 90, intelligence: 62, leadership: 68, agility: 88, luck: 62 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9050,9 +9050,9 @@ export const fifteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 15,
     exp: 94,
-    hp: 62,
+    hp: 54,
     maxHp: 62,
-    attack: 20,
+    attack: 18,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 92, intelligence: 62, leadership: 80, agility: 70, luck: 61 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9071,9 +9071,9 @@ export const fifteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 15,
     exp: 94,
-    hp: 62,
+    hp: 54,
     maxHp: 62,
-    attack: 20,
+    attack: 18,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 92, intelligence: 62, leadership: 80, agility: 70, luck: 61 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9092,9 +9092,9 @@ export const fifteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 16,
     exp: 96,
-    hp: 64,
+    hp: 54,
     maxHp: 64,
-    attack: 21,
+    attack: 18,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 94, intelligence: 63, leadership: 82, agility: 71, luck: 62 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9113,9 +9113,9 @@ export const fifteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 16,
     exp: 96,
-    hp: 64,
+    hp: 54,
     maxHp: 64,
-    attack: 21,
+    attack: 18,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 94, intelligence: 63, leadership: 82, agility: 71, luck: 62 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9134,9 +9134,9 @@ export const fifteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'archer',
     level: 15,
     exp: 94,
-    hp: 50,
+    hp: 42,
     maxHp: 50,
-    attack: 20,
+    attack: 18,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 83, intelligence: 74, leadership: 72, agility: 84, luck: 62 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9155,9 +9155,9 @@ export const fifteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'archer',
     level: 15,
     exp: 94,
-    hp: 50,
+    hp: 42,
     maxHp: 50,
-    attack: 20,
+    attack: 18,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 83, intelligence: 74, leadership: 72, agility: 84, luck: 62 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9176,9 +9176,9 @@ export const fifteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'archer',
     level: 16,
     exp: 96,
-    hp: 52,
+    hp: 32,
     maxHp: 52,
-    attack: 21,
+    attack: 16,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 84, intelligence: 75, leadership: 73, agility: 85, luck: 63 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9260,9 +9260,9 @@ export const fifteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 16,
     exp: 98,
-    hp: 70,
+    hp: 54,
     maxHp: 70,
-    attack: 22,
+    attack: 20,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 96, intelligence: 64, leadership: 84, agility: 70, luck: 62 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9281,9 +9281,9 @@ export const fifteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 16,
     exp: 98,
-    hp: 70,
-    maxHp: 70,
-    attack: 22,
+    hp: 36,
+    maxHp: 64,
+    attack: 17,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 96, intelligence: 64, leadership: 84, agility: 70, luck: 62 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9302,9 +9302,9 @@ export const fifteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 16,
     exp: 98,
-    hp: 70,
-    maxHp: 70,
-    attack: 22,
+    hp: 36,
+    maxHp: 64,
+    attack: 17,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 96, intelligence: 64, leadership: 84, agility: 70, luck: 62 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9323,9 +9323,9 @@ export const fifteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'archer',
     level: 16,
     exp: 98,
-    hp: 54,
-    maxHp: 54,
-    attack: 22,
+    hp: 36,
+    maxHp: 50,
+    attack: 17,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 70, intelligence: 88, leadership: 78, agility: 76, luck: 66 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9344,9 +9344,9 @@ export const fifteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'rebelLeader',
     level: 18,
     exp: 12,
-    hp: 92,
+    hp: 48,
     maxHp: 92,
-    attack: 26,
+    attack: 18,
     move: 4,
     stats: { might: 104, intelligence: 58, leadership: 90, agility: 82, luck: 64 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9531,9 +9531,9 @@ export const sixteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'archer',
     level: 17,
     exp: 12,
-    hp: 54,
-    maxHp: 54,
-    attack: 22,
+    hp: 48,
+    maxHp: 48,
+    attack: 20,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 86, intelligence: 78, leadership: 76, agility: 86, luck: 64 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9552,9 +9552,9 @@ export const sixteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'archer',
     level: 17,
     exp: 12,
-    hp: 54,
-    maxHp: 54,
-    attack: 22,
+    hp: 36,
+    maxHp: 36,
+    attack: 17,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 86, intelligence: 78, leadership: 76, agility: 86, luck: 64 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9573,9 +9573,9 @@ export const sixteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'archer',
     level: 17,
     exp: 12,
-    hp: 54,
-    maxHp: 54,
-    attack: 22,
+    hp: 48,
+    maxHp: 48,
+    attack: 20,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 86, intelligence: 78, leadership: 76, agility: 86, luck: 64 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9636,9 +9636,9 @@ export const sixteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'cavalry',
     level: 17,
     exp: 12,
-    hp: 70,
-    maxHp: 70,
-    attack: 24,
+    hp: 66,
+    maxHp: 66,
+    attack: 23,
     move: 5,
     stats: { might: 100, intelligence: 60, leadership: 78, agility: 94, luck: 65 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9657,9 +9657,9 @@ export const sixteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'cavalry',
     level: 18,
     exp: 14,
-    hp: 74,
-    maxHp: 74,
-    attack: 25,
+    hp: 58,
+    maxHp: 68,
+    attack: 20,
     move: 5,
     stats: { might: 102, intelligence: 62, leadership: 80, agility: 95, luck: 66 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9678,9 +9678,9 @@ export const sixteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 18,
     exp: 14,
-    hp: 74,
-    maxHp: 74,
-    attack: 24,
+    hp: 44,
+    maxHp: 44,
+    attack: 19,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 100, intelligence: 66, leadership: 88, agility: 72, luck: 64 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9699,9 +9699,9 @@ export const sixteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 18,
     exp: 14,
-    hp: 74,
-    maxHp: 74,
-    attack: 24,
+    hp: 44,
+    maxHp: 44,
+    attack: 19,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 100, intelligence: 66, leadership: 88, agility: 72, luck: 64 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9720,9 +9720,9 @@ export const sixteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'archer',
     level: 18,
     exp: 14,
-    hp: 58,
-    maxHp: 58,
-    attack: 23,
+    hp: 36,
+    maxHp: 36,
+    attack: 17,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 72, intelligence: 90, leadership: 80, agility: 78, luck: 66 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9741,9 +9741,9 @@ export const sixteenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'rebelLeader',
     level: 19,
     exp: 18,
-    hp: 98,
-    maxHp: 98,
-    attack: 27,
+    hp: 70,
+    maxHp: 90,
+    attack: 20,
     move: 4,
     stats: { might: 106, intelligence: 74, leadership: 96, agility: 80, luck: 66 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9781,9 +9781,9 @@ export const seventeenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'bandit',
     level: 18,
     exp: 16,
-    hp: 58,
+    hp: 52,
     maxHp: 58,
-    attack: 22,
+    attack: 20,
     move: 4,
     stats: { might: 94, intelligence: 66, leadership: 72, agility: 92, luck: 64 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9802,9 +9802,9 @@ export const seventeenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'bandit',
     level: 18,
     exp: 16,
-    hp: 58,
+    hp: 52,
     maxHp: 58,
-    attack: 22,
+    attack: 20,
     move: 4,
     stats: { might: 94, intelligence: 66, leadership: 72, agility: 92, luck: 64 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9823,9 +9823,9 @@ export const seventeenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 18,
     exp: 18,
-    hp: 70,
+    hp: 62,
     maxHp: 70,
-    attack: 24,
+    attack: 21,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 100, intelligence: 68, leadership: 86, agility: 74, luck: 64 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9844,9 +9844,9 @@ export const seventeenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 18,
     exp: 18,
-    hp: 70,
+    hp: 62,
     maxHp: 70,
-    attack: 24,
+    attack: 21,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 100, intelligence: 68, leadership: 86, agility: 74, luck: 64 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9865,9 +9865,9 @@ export const seventeenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 19,
     exp: 20,
-    hp: 74,
-    maxHp: 74,
-    attack: 25,
+    hp: 52,
+    maxHp: 68,
+    attack: 19,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 102, intelligence: 70, leadership: 88, agility: 74, luck: 65 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9886,9 +9886,9 @@ export const seventeenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 19,
     exp: 20,
-    hp: 74,
-    maxHp: 74,
-    attack: 25,
+    hp: 52,
+    maxHp: 68,
+    attack: 19,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 102, intelligence: 70, leadership: 88, agility: 74, luck: 65 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9928,9 +9928,9 @@ export const seventeenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'archer',
     level: 18,
     exp: 18,
-    hp: 56,
-    maxHp: 56,
-    attack: 23,
+    hp: 44,
+    maxHp: 50,
+    attack: 18,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 88, intelligence: 80, leadership: 78, agility: 88, luck: 65 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9949,9 +9949,9 @@ export const seventeenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'archer',
     level: 19,
     exp: 20,
-    hp: 58,
-    maxHp: 58,
-    attack: 24,
+    hp: 40,
+    maxHp: 50,
+    attack: 17,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 90, intelligence: 82, leadership: 80, agility: 88, luck: 66 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9970,9 +9970,9 @@ export const seventeenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'cavalry',
     level: 19,
     exp: 20,
-    hp: 76,
+    hp: 62,
     maxHp: 76,
-    attack: 26,
+    attack: 22,
     move: 5,
     stats: { might: 104, intelligence: 64, leadership: 82, agility: 96, luck: 66 },
     equipment: {
@@ -9991,9 +9991,9 @@ export const seventeenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'cavalry',
     level: 19,
     exp: 20,
-    hp: 76,
+    hp: 62,
     maxHp: 76,
-    attack: 26,
+    attack: 22,
     move: 5,
     stats: { might: 104, intelligence: 64, leadership: 82, agility: 96, luck: 66 },
     equipment: {
@@ -10012,9 +10012,9 @@ export const seventeenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 19,
     exp: 22,
-    hp: 78,
-    maxHp: 78,
-    attack: 25,
+    hp: 52,
+    maxHp: 66,
+    attack: 20,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 102, intelligence: 74, leadership: 90, agility: 75, luck: 65 },
     equipment: {
@@ -10033,9 +10033,9 @@ export const seventeenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 19,
     exp: 22,
-    hp: 78,
-    maxHp: 78,
-    attack: 25,
+    hp: 52,
+    maxHp: 66,
+    attack: 20,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 102, intelligence: 74, leadership: 90, agility: 75, luck: 65 },
     equipment: {
@@ -10054,9 +10054,9 @@ export const seventeenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'archer',
     level: 19,
     exp: 22,
-    hp: 60,
-    maxHp: 60,
-    attack: 24,
+    hp: 40,
+    maxHp: 52,
+    attack: 18,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 74, intelligence: 92, leadership: 82, agility: 80, luck: 68 },
     equipment: {
@@ -10075,9 +10075,9 @@ export const seventeenthBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'rebelLeader',
     level: 20,
     exp: 24,
-    hp: 104,
+    hp: 72,
     maxHp: 104,
-    attack: 28,
+    attack: 22,
     move: 4,
     stats: { might: 108, intelligence: 76, leadership: 98, agility: 82, luck: 66 },
     equipment: {
@@ -10831,8 +10831,8 @@ const twentiethBattleAllyPositions: Record<string, { x: number; y: number }> = {
   'zhang-fei': { x: 6, y: 23 },
   'jian-yong': { x: 3, y: 24 },
   'mi-zhu': { x: 5, y: 25 },
-  'sun-qian': { x: 7, y: 22 },
-  'zhao-yun': { x: 8, y: 20 },
+  'sun-qian': { x: 4, y: 24 },
+  'zhao-yun': { x: 8, y: 21 },
   'zhuge-liang': { x: 6, y: 21 }
 };
 
@@ -10852,9 +10852,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'bandit',
     level: 24,
     exp: 34,
-    hp: 70,
-    maxHp: 70,
-    attack: 27,
+    hp: 44,
+    maxHp: 56,
+    attack: 18,
     move: 4,
     stats: { might: 102, intelligence: 74, leadership: 80, agility: 100, luck: 70 },
     equipment: {
@@ -10862,7 +10862,7 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
       armor: { itemId: 'rebel-vest', level: 3, exp: 4 },
       accessory: { itemId: 'grain-pouch', level: 1, exp: 0 }
     },
-    x: 13,
+    x: 14,
     y: 21
   },
   {
@@ -10873,9 +10873,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'bandit',
     level: 24,
     exp: 34,
-    hp: 70,
-    maxHp: 70,
-    attack: 27,
+    hp: 56,
+    maxHp: 56,
+    attack: 23,
     move: 4,
     stats: { might: 102, intelligence: 74, leadership: 80, agility: 100, luck: 70 },
     equipment: {
@@ -10883,7 +10883,7 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
       armor: { itemId: 'rebel-vest', level: 3, exp: 4 },
       accessory: { itemId: 'grain-pouch', level: 1, exp: 0 }
     },
-    x: 14,
+    x: 15,
     y: 24
   },
   {
@@ -10894,9 +10894,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'cavalry',
     level: 25,
     exp: 36,
-    hp: 94,
-    maxHp: 94,
-    attack: 32,
+    hp: 74,
+    maxHp: 86,
+    attack: 26,
     move: 5,
     stats: { might: 116, intelligence: 74, leadership: 92, agility: 110, luck: 72 },
     equipment: {
@@ -10904,7 +10904,7 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
       armor: { itemId: 'lamellar-armor', level: 3, exp: 18 },
       accessory: { itemId: 'bravery-token', level: 1, exp: 0 }
     },
-    x: 17,
+    x: 19,
     y: 19
   },
   {
@@ -10915,9 +10915,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'cavalry',
     level: 25,
     exp: 36,
-    hp: 94,
-    maxHp: 94,
-    attack: 32,
+    hp: 74,
+    maxHp: 86,
+    attack: 26,
     move: 5,
     stats: { might: 116, intelligence: 74, leadership: 92, agility: 110, luck: 72 },
     equipment: {
@@ -10925,7 +10925,7 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
       armor: { itemId: 'lamellar-armor', level: 3, exp: 18 },
       accessory: { itemId: 'bravery-token', level: 1, exp: 0 }
     },
-    x: 18,
+    x: 20,
     y: 23
   },
   {
@@ -10936,9 +10936,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'cavalry',
     level: 26,
     exp: 38,
-    hp: 98,
-    maxHp: 98,
-    attack: 33,
+    hp: 64,
+    maxHp: 92,
+    attack: 24,
     move: 5,
     stats: { might: 118, intelligence: 76, leadership: 94, agility: 112, luck: 72 },
     equipment: {
@@ -10957,9 +10957,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'cavalry',
     level: 26,
     exp: 38,
-    hp: 98,
-    maxHp: 98,
-    attack: 33,
+    hp: 64,
+    maxHp: 92,
+    attack: 24,
     move: 5,
     stats: { might: 118, intelligence: 76, leadership: 94, agility: 112, luck: 72 },
     equipment: {
@@ -10978,9 +10978,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 24,
     exp: 34,
-    hp: 88,
+    hp: 72,
     maxHp: 88,
-    attack: 29,
+    attack: 25,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 110, intelligence: 76, leadership: 94, agility: 82, luck: 70 },
     equipment: {
@@ -10999,9 +10999,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 24,
     exp: 34,
-    hp: 88,
+    hp: 72,
     maxHp: 88,
-    attack: 29,
+    attack: 25,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 110, intelligence: 76, leadership: 94, agility: 82, luck: 70 },
     equipment: {
@@ -11020,9 +11020,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 25,
     exp: 36,
-    hp: 92,
+    hp: 64,
     maxHp: 92,
-    attack: 30,
+    attack: 24,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 112, intelligence: 78, leadership: 96, agility: 84, luck: 71 },
     equipment: {
@@ -11041,9 +11041,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 25,
     exp: 36,
-    hp: 92,
+    hp: 64,
     maxHp: 92,
-    attack: 30,
+    attack: 24,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 112, intelligence: 78, leadership: 96, agility: 84, luck: 71 },
     equipment: {
@@ -11062,9 +11062,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'archer',
     level: 24,
     exp: 34,
-    hp: 68,
+    hp: 56,
     maxHp: 68,
-    attack: 29,
+    attack: 24,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 98, intelligence: 88, leadership: 86, agility: 96, luck: 72 },
     equipment: {
@@ -11083,9 +11083,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'archer',
     level: 24,
     exp: 34,
-    hp: 68,
+    hp: 56,
     maxHp: 68,
-    attack: 29,
+    attack: 24,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 98, intelligence: 88, leadership: 86, agility: 96, luck: 72 },
     equipment: {
@@ -11104,9 +11104,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'archer',
     level: 25,
     exp: 36,
-    hp: 70,
-    maxHp: 70,
-    attack: 30,
+    hp: 44,
+    maxHp: 52,
+    attack: 22,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 100, intelligence: 90, leadership: 88, agility: 98, luck: 72 },
     equipment: {
@@ -11125,9 +11125,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 26,
     exp: 38,
-    hp: 100,
-    maxHp: 100,
-    attack: 32,
+    hp: 52,
+    maxHp: 84,
+    attack: 22,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 118, intelligence: 80, leadership: 104, agility: 86, luck: 72 },
     equipment: {
@@ -11146,9 +11146,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'yellowTurban',
     level: 26,
     exp: 38,
-    hp: 100,
-    maxHp: 100,
-    attack: 32,
+    hp: 52,
+    maxHp: 84,
+    attack: 22,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 118, intelligence: 80, leadership: 104, agility: 86, luck: 72 },
     equipment: {
@@ -11167,9 +11167,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'archer',
     level: 25,
     exp: 36,
-    hp: 72,
-    maxHp: 72,
-    attack: 29,
+    hp: 52,
+    maxHp: 64,
+    attack: 23,
     move: 3,
     stats: { might: 78, intelligence: 98, leadership: 90, agility: 86, luck: 74 },
     equipment: {
@@ -11188,9 +11188,9 @@ export const twentiethBattleUnits: UnitData[] = [
     classKey: 'rebelLeader',
     level: 27,
     exp: 42,
-    hp: 132,
+    hp: 84,
     maxHp: 132,
-    attack: 34,
+    attack: 26,
     move: 4,
     stats: { might: 120, intelligence: 86, leadership: 112, agility: 90, luck: 76 },
     equipment: {
diff --git a/src/game/scenes/BattleScene.ts b/src/game/scenes/BattleScene.ts
index fcf6685..9e954ec 100644
--- a/src/game/scenes/BattleScene.ts
+++ b/src/game/scenes/BattleScene.ts
@@ -1609,8 +1609,8 @@ const enemyAiByUnitId: Record<string, EnemyAiBehavior> = {
   'liu-biao-road-archer-d': 'hold',
   'liu-biao-road-cavalry-a': 'aggressive',
   'liu-biao-road-cavalry-b': 'aggressive',
-  'liu-biao-road-cavalry-c': 'aggressive',
-  'liu-biao-road-cavalry-d': 'aggressive',
+  'liu-biao-road-cavalry-c': 'guard',
+  'liu-biao-road-cavalry-d': 'guard',
   'liu-biao-road-guard-a': 'guard',
   'liu-biao-road-guard-b': 'guard',
   'liu-biao-road-strategist-a': 'hold',
@@ -1667,8 +1667,8 @@ const enemyAiByUnitId: Record<string, EnemyAiBehavior> = {
   'envoy-road-scout-b': 'aggressive',
   'envoy-road-cavalry-a': 'aggressive',
   'envoy-road-cavalry-b': 'aggressive',
-  'envoy-road-cavalry-c': 'aggressive',
-  'envoy-road-cavalry-d': 'aggressive',
+  'envoy-road-cavalry-c': 'guard',
+  'envoy-road-cavalry-d': 'guard',
   'envoy-road-infantry-a': 'guard',
   'envoy-road-infantry-b': 'guard',
   'envoy-road-infantry-c': 'guard',
diff --git a/src/game/scenes/CampScene.ts b/src/game/scenes/CampScene.ts
index 3c7367d..b4af0e5 100644
--- a/src/game/scenes/CampScene.ts
+++ b/src/game/scenes/CampScene.ts
@@ -742,9 +742,9 @@ const sortieRulesByBattleId: Partial<Record<BattleScenarioId, SortieRuleDefiniti
       { unitId: 'sun-qian', reason: '문서와 외교 명분을 지니고 있어 이번 전투의 생존 목표입니다.' },
       { unitId: 'zhao-yun', reason: '추격 기병을 끊고 사절의 측면을 지키는 데 좋습니다.' },
       { unitId: 'guan-yu', reason: '강나루 보병과 포구 수비대를 받아낼 전열 핵심입니다.' },
-      { unitId: 'mi-zhu', reason: '사절 보급과 장기전 회복 운용에 유리합니다.' }
+      { unitId: 'zhang-fei', reason: '포구 수비대를 빠르게 흔들어 사절단이 길게 물리지 않게 합니다.' }
     ],
-    note: '강동 사절로는 전투력만으로 고르기 어렵습니다. 제갈량과 손건을 보호하면서 전열, 기동, 보급 중 무엇을 남길지 선택하십시오.'
+    note: '강동 사절로는 보호 대상이 많은 전장입니다. 제갈량과 손건을 뒤에 두고, 관우·장비·조운으로 전열과 기동을 두껍게 세우십시오.'
   },
   'twenty-first-battle-red-cliffs-vanguard': {
     maxUnits: 6,